Clara Mast has fled Idaho amidst a scandal. She returned from her Rumspringa, with more than she bargained for, but was she to blame? Unable to handle the way she is treated she travels to Faith's Creek for a new start.

Jesse Zook's sisters are visiting from Idaho. Though he tries to be nice, he can't wait for the spiteful women to leave. On the bright side, he notices a beautiful newcomer and tries to get her to speak to him.

Clara has had enough of men, but Jesse seems different. She finally lets her guard down as she attends the quilting circle and allows herself to think of finding love. Unfortunately, her past comes roaring back to haunt her.

Will Clara run away from her budding romance with Jesse? Will he be shocked when he learns her secret or will he convince her she belongs in Faith's Creek by his side?