The kingdom of Meadowhelm has long been plagued by the fear instilled by Peter Pan and his Lost Boys. Each year, Peter comes to Meadowhelm and names his price for another year of peace. When Peter throws a wrench in the works and asks that Princess Holly return with him, he is rejected, and Holly's life quickly begins to spiral out of control. Angry but benevolent, Peter gives Holly a fortnight to prepare herself to leave. Just as it seems that all hope is lost, an infamous pirate captain who hasn't been seen in many years shows up in Meadowhelm's harbor with promises of keeping the princess safe. Now Holly must make a choice before it is made for her one way or another.