Thirty-six-year-old Spencer Highland is generally happy with his lot in life. He's got a great social circle, a job as a voice actor and audiobook narrator (which he loves), and a cat he's pretty sure owns his soul. But, since his last breakup, he's been lonely. He wants to mean something to someone again. Wants to take care of someone again.

He wants to be someone's Daddy again.

Unfortunately, courtesy of his personal hang-ups, putting himself back out there doesn't feel as easy as it sounds on paper.

Meanwhile, Tony Russo is a twenty-eight-year-old man who is convinced that he does not have his life together in the least. He's working a job which makes him miserable, and he knows he doesn't fit in anywhere but with his sister. He's never felt 'normal'.

Then there's Tony's embarrassing secret. He's a virgin. A twenty-eight-year-old virgin addicted to listening to kinky romance audiobooks.

After an embarrassing encounter, Tony finds himself connecting with Spencer in a way he's never connected with another person before. Tony is also blown away by the idea that his favorite narrator might be at all interested in him, too. But will Spencer still be interested when he finds out just how unintentionally high maintenance Tony is? Or, worse, what will Spencer say when he learns Tony's secret?

On the other side of the coin, Tony is exactly what Spencer's been missing, and Spencer plans to do everything in his power to make sure Tony understands how truly special he is.