Wendy Darling never imagined she would live in any other time than the early 20th century, nor did she ever see herself living in any place besides England. But after a journey with Peter gone askew, she finds herself in 21st century USA.

Years later while at a fencing class, she is shocked to discover that Captain Hook (Evan Roberts) is there as well. He is ready for change and has left his villainy behind in Neverland. The long-held attraction between them surfaces, and only intensifies each time they see each other.

As Wendy sees positive change in Evan, but no change in Peter's narcissistic and selfish behavior, her belief of Evan as a villain and Peter as a hero are upturned. Can she trust the former Captain Hook with her heart, and will Peter ever grow up?